Best Croquet Set for 2021 (Includes Amish & Scotsdale Reviews)
What is the best croquet set on the market? That’s exactly what we will look into today.
Whether you’re after a quality, Amish set with handcrafted components; a cheap and cheerful budget option, or maybe something in between – we have a croquet set here for you.
Taking a series of products from a range of price points we have aimed to provide the ultimate review and buyer’s guide.
For our findings at a glance, just head to the table below. For full reviews of each of our choices, keep on reading.
Best Croquet Set – Top 5
TOP PREMIUM PICK: Amish-Crafted
8 Player Set
BEST BUDGET: Maggift Croquet
6 Player Set
6 Player Set
32" Wooden Mallets
6 Player Set
30" Wooden Mallets
6 Mallets, 6 Balls
9 wickets, 2 posts
Croquet Set Reviews
A little history
Croquet is a popular outdoor game that has been around since the early part of the 19th Century. The origins of the game we play today can be traced back to England in 1852.
It was in this year that a game known as ‘Crooky’ found its way across from Ireland, (the origins there date back to the 1830s).
As became evident, this popular lawn game quickly found its way across the British Empire as well as most of Western Europe.
To this day, the game appeals across the classes. The traditional image of the well-to-do playing croquet across manicured lawns in between sips of Pimms remains, but the fact is any family or group of friends can enjoy a round of croquet as long as they have a working set and a patch of grass to play on.
And on the subject of croquet sets, there is a number to choose from. As promised we have selected 5 of the best from within a range of price points to give the ultimate low down.
So if you’re ready, let’s jump in and take a look…
- Related Content: 8 Top Tips to keep your Garden fresh and clean
1. TOP PREMIUM PICK: The Amish-crafted Deluxe with 8-Player Croquet Game Set, has Maple Hardwood(s)
This is an old fashioned maple hardwood croquet set crafted in Lancaster County by Amish folks. The set has six maple mallets and they are lathe-turned.
Each end of the mallet head has a polished brass ring. This protects the head from smashing or cracking.
This top-quality croquet set helps keep your game organized since it comes with a ready-to-play wooden holder.
The balls in this set are made from plastic polymer making the balls durable while the metal wickets are vinyl-coated. The metal wickets will not bend easily and they are quite substantial.
This is a beautiful croquet set packed with a stylish design and finish. With the top quality Amish craftwork going into its build, this is a very sturdy set that will last for many years. As a result, it gets our top pick choice with no hesitation.
To top it all off, it comes with a handy wooden storage kit that will help ensure your set remains in tip-top condition.
2. BEST BUDGET PICK: The MAGGIFT with the Six Player Croquet Set Carrying Bag, that is 26-Inch
The MAGGIFT 6 player croquet set is perfect to be played at family gatherings or picnics. The set comprises of weather-resistant molded balls and vinyl-coated wickets. The hardwood mallet and handles are easy to install.
It will only take you a few seconds to install the handles since you will only need to screw the handle into the mallet. The MAGGIFT croquet set can be played by two to six players.
The hardwood mallets are fitted with caps for added protection. The set comes equipped with the following:
- Six 26inches hardwood handles.
- Six 8inches hardwood mallets that are fitted with caps for more protection.
- Nine steel wickets that are vinyl-coated.
- Six weather-resistant balls.
The main objective of the MAGGIFT croquet set is to race your opponents around the wickets and get to hit the finishing stake.
Ensure that whenever children are using this croquet set they are under the supervision of adults.
The MAGGIFT with the Six Player Croquet Set Carrying Bag, which is 26-Inch is a croquet set that can be played by players of different ages and abilities. It is easy to install and easy to carry around since it comes with a carrying bag.
For increased protection, the hardwood mallets are equipped with caps. The set is also easy to store since the mallets can be taken apart for storage.
This croquet set can be used during family gatherings or picnics since a maximum of eight players can use it in one go. The price of this croquet set is affordable and it gives you value for your money. This is the reason why we recommend it as the best budget buy.
3. BEST VALUE PICK: The Six-Player Deluxe Croquet Set of Wooden Mallets, by Crown Sporting Goods
This is a croquet set that offers players a convenient set in one. It includes 32 inches hardwood mallets fitted with rubber caps for extra protection.
It also has two hardwood stakes, 9 vinyl-coated steel wickets, 6 weather-resistant polymer balls, and a carrying bag.
Setting this croquet set is very easy to set up and is crafted from high-quality materials. The set includes 6 mallets that are made using hardwood.
This ensures that you are able to achieve an accurate and most effective experience while playing.
The mallets have cylindrical heads and octagonal handles perfect for garden croquet and yet strong enough to withstand a serious game of croquet.
The set is also simple to transport since it comes with a durable carrying bag that can be used to carry all the equipment. All you need is to strap it on your back and literally carry it everywhere.
Of all the best croquet sets this is the best value set. This is because the croquet set offers players more convenience since it comes with a complete set. It has an excellent design and finishes.
From the balls to the wickets, the set is built to last for many years. The durable carrying bag with a zipper ensures that all the equipment can easily be transported almost everywhere.
Another thing that adds to the value is that a large group of people can use the set making it perfect for picnics or large family gatherings.
- Related Content: Best tennis stringing machines on the market – A Top 5 Review
4. The Scottsdale’s Croquet Set by the North Meadow
The Scottsdale’s Croquet Set by North Meadow comes with 6 polymer balls, heavy wickets that come with their own storage bags, a canvas carrying bag, and 24 inches goal stakes.
The set offers players convenience, high quality, reliability, and attractiveness. It can easily be played by 6 players comfortably at a go.
The mallets are made from hard maple which is one of the most durable and resistant materials in the market. This offers players excellent hitting quality.
This best croquet set offers players convenience and reliability since it has been made using reliable and durable maple wood. It is easy to transport the set because it comes with a large canvas carrying bag that fits all the equipment comfortably.
It is resistant to scratches and moisture since it has been coated using high-quality material. The coating not only makes it attractive but also very sturdy.
Assembling the set is also very easy because each mallet comes with its own color and they are easy to assemble.
5. The GoSports Premium Croquet Set(s) for the Adults & Kids – Choose Between the Deluxe and Standard
This is complete croquet set from GoSports, that comes complete with six balls, six color mallets, nine wickets and two end posts. Also included in the set is a carrying bag which makes the set nice and portable.
The set has premium construction to feature a modern construction and durability.
The modern design makes the set look attractive in any lawn or backyard. The set can be played by players of different ages and ability.
This is the best croquet set that has some desirable features. It is made using high-quality wood which makes the set durable. Transporting this set is easy since it comes with a carrying bag that allows users to store and organize all the equipment comfortably.
The set can be played by players of different ages and abilities making it perfect for picnics and large family gatherings.
It has a modern and unique construction which makes it quite attractive on your backyard or lawn.
The Vintage Croquet Set
Beyond that, it could be a needle in the haystack type affair of visiting yard sales and vintage stores in the hope that you might come across one.
The Amish croquet sets do follow the vintage aesthetic quite closely, so as a contemporary solution you may well look there too.
- Related Content: Top 10 Tips for a perfect summer BBQ
What to Consider when Buying a Croquet Set
Who is it for?
One of the first issues to consider is who will be using the croquet set.
Something for the summer months to have some fun with the children will be different from a set designed for adults and teenagers that might last several years.
The fundamental aspect here is the size of the set. So let’s break that down by dividing available croquet sets into two groups:
So let’s first divide croquet sets into two groups:
- Sets for children
- Sets for teenager/adults
The length of the mallet shaft is the main differentiator here; as is the weight of the mallet and ball.
Croquet Sets for Children
Croquet sets for children will have mallet shafts between 24 and 29 inches long. This is a great size for a child as they will be able to control and swing the mallet.
For an adult, however, this length range means you would need to bend over quite considerably to hold the shaft and swing the mallet.
Most mallets for young players will weigh less than two pounds, with the balls coming in at around 8 ounces. These are lighter, so the child does not need to swing so hard to make the ball move over greater distances.
This lightweight nature is especially helpful in a normal backyard, where the grass is more unkempt than a designated croquet court.
Court size for children
The USCA Official 9 wicket court is 50 X 100 feet; this is too large for children to comfortably play, (and for the average household lawn dimensions). 25 X 50 feet is a much better size for young players.
Croquet Sets for Teenagers & Adults
Sets for older players have a standard size 36-inch mallet shaft length. (A few sets utilize 34 or 32-inch shafts.)
As with the sets designed for children, anything shorter than 32 inches becomes difficult for the average adult frame to use.
Harder woods are used for adult sets. It is common to see robust materials such as maple, oak, and hickory used for the mallets and shafts.
Not only does this make the adult sets more expensive, but these components also weigh a great deal more, with the mallets being closer to two and a half pounds each.
The balls are larger (3 5/16 inches), and heavier (around 12 ounces) than those used in children croquet sets.
Court size for adults
Regarding court size, if you have space a ¾ of the full USCA 9 wicket court is great. The grass should be as short as possible, however.
6 ball or 4 ball set?
Whether you purchase a six-ball or a four-ball set is dependent on the number of players you expect to have at any one time.
For some family sets, 4 balls are enough.
That being said, the majority of backyard croquet sets available online, opt for the six-ball combination with 6 mallets and nine wickets.
In fact, the traditional “American 9 Wicket Croquet” set has been 6 balls since its adoption from the British, (who interestingly throughout the Empire, opted for four balls and six wickets approach).
A word about the Extras
Finally, there are a number of extras that will impact the overall quality and cost of a croquet set.
Boundary strings and corner pegs are one such addition that will not be available in all sets but is definitely good to have.
Nylon string will normally come in 500-foot spools. Corner pegs will be made from dowel or narrow board.
In high-quality sets, you may even get colored pegs with mounted flags.
Storage is another consideration. Lower budget options should at least come packaged in A lightweight nylon bag. The benefit of this is that one person can easily carry the bag, and put it in the trunk for transportation.
A traditional wooden box is aesthetically pleasing and is the approach premium Amish style croquet sets might adopt, however, they are slightly more impractical.
A wooden trolley is a nice touch, as this can be wheeled out to the court when it comes time to play.
We are hopeful that you have been able to pick useful buying tips from this review. It will be wise if you compared the pros and cons of the products that we have selected, as well as check the price to see if a given set falls into your budget.
This will help you make an informed purchase which will not only give you value for your money but give you a wonderful gaming experience too.
- United States Croquet Association
- Croquet World Online Magazine
- Croquet Network
- 9 Wicket Croquet: Backyard Basics
- Sunni Overend and Roslyn Oades; The Rules of Backyard Croquet
- Jack Osborn and Jesse Kornbluth; Winning Croquet: From Backyard to Greenward, the Skills, Strategies, and Rules of America’s Classic Outdoor Sport (Simon & Schuster Books)
- James Hawkins; Complete Croquet: A Guide to Skills, Tactics, and Strategy (Crowood Press)
- Andy Tooken; Croquet Basics: How to Play Croquet (Createspace)